The LTR Genie Score of Hilo, HI is 63, indicating a moderate level of attractiveness for long-term rental investment. This score is influenced by the stable LTR rentability and net ROI of 17.3%, although the lack of rent growth may be a concern for some investors. On the other hand, the STR Genie Score of 76 suggests a high level of attractiveness for short-term rental investment, with a higher net ROI of 22.43% and strong occupancy rate of 67.86%.

Hilo, HI is a popular tourist destination known for its natural beauty, including waterfalls, botanical gardens, and black sand beaches. The town also has a strong cultural heritage, with events like the Merrie Monarch Festival showcasing traditional hula dance. These factors contribute to the high STR Genie Score, as tourists are likely to seek short-term rental accommodations in the area.

Based on the metrics provided, Hilo, HI appears to be a more attractive market for short-term rental investment due to the higher STR Genie Score and potential for higher returns. However, investors should consider the unique characteristics of the market and their own investment goals before making a decision.